American Cheese Substitutes 7 Ideas To Try Right Now

American cheese has been around since the early 1900s. It was first created by accident when a dairy farmer accidentally left a piece of cheddar cheese out too long.

Today, American cheese is one of the most popular cheeses in the world. It’s also one of the most controversial. Many people love it while others hate it. Cheese from the United States. It’s nice and silky, melty, and has a rich golden hue that goes with everything.

Yes, it is the cheese that the majority of people enjoy and with which you may have grown up. But what if you run out of American cheese for whatever reason? So, how do you go about it? Perhaps you’re cooking a recipe that asks for American cheese and you’d want to substitute another variety. Whatever the situation maybe, you’ll need a few stand-ins. Fortunately, we have exactly the list for you!

Best American cheese substitute

American cheese has been around since the early 1900s. It was originally created to mimic the taste of Swiss cheese. However, it wasn’t until the 1950’s that it became popular.

Today, there are many different types of American cheeses out there. Some are even vegan-friendly. In this article, I am going to share with you some of the best American cheese substitutes that you can use instead of real American cheese.


This type of cheese originated in Wisconsin. Colby cheese is made using pasteurized milk. This means that all bacteria will be killed off during processing. The result is a milder flavor than regular American cheese.

The texture of Colby cheese is similar to mozzarella or provolone. You can find it at grocery stores as well as specialty food shops. If you like your cheese on the softer side, then try substituting it for American cheese. Because it’s one of the major components of American cheese, Colby is by far the most popular alternative (more on that in a minute). Colby won’t have much sharpness because it’s such a mellow cheese. It’s a mellow, sweet cheese with a light appearance. It also melts nicely and is readily available in stores and supermarkets.

See also  Can you eat a seagull? (5 Compelling reasons not to)


If you’ve ever had Cheddar cheese before, then you know just how good it tastes. There are so many varieties of Cheddars out there today. They come in various shapes, sizes, flavors, and textures. One thing they all have in common though is their ability to meet very easily. That makes them great alternatives for American cheese.

You should always check labels carefully before buying any kind of cheese. Make sure that it says "cheddar" somewhere on the label. Cheddar, the second half of the American cheese pair, adds spiciness and bite to the combination. Annatto, a spice that also serves as a food coloring, is responsible for the spicy, nutty flavors. If you’re using Cheddar, make sure it’s a young, soft kind; older, crumblier varieties won’t work.

Monterey Jack

Another favorite among Americans, Monterey jack is an excellent choice when making sandwiches. Its smooth consistency allows it to melt into anything without leaving behind too much of its own cheesy taste. It comes in both shredded and block form. Shredded versions tend to be more affordable but blocks are usually better quality.

Like other kinds of cheddar, Monterey jack contains an annatto. It gives the cheese a slightly orange color and a bit of heat. If you don’t have any Cheddar on hand, Monterey Jack will suffice. It’s similar to Colby, but with the addition of annatto. In fact, if you don’t want to use two varieties of cheese, this could be the greatest alternative. It has a delicate texture and a sweet finish since it is produced after the Colby recipe. The use of annatto gives it a wonderful Cheddar flavor.

See also  Best Polenta Substitutes 3 Ideas To Try For Dinner

Mild Gouda

Goudas are often used in cooking due to their rich, buttery flavor. Mild gouda is not only delicious, but it’s also easy to substitute for American cheese. Like other kinds of cheese, it needs to be aged properly. Aged gouda develops a stronger flavor over time.

When choosing a brand, look for ones that say "mild." These are typically lower in fat content. If you’re searching for a milder American cheese, Gouda is a good choice. Both Gouda and Colby can be used in place of one another, or you can use both with a pinch of Cheddar. If you’re going to use Gouda, go for the mild, young kind because the aged version will be considerably sweeter. It takes on caramel flavors and becomes extremely nutty.


This type of cheese originated in Germany. Muensters are made from cow milk and contain no additives. This means that they are naturally low-fat and high in protein. Their creamy texture makes them perfect for melting. When melted, muenster tends to become runny, which is why it works best in sandwich recipes.

Because of its unique properties, muenster is considered hard cheese. Hard cheeses are generally harder than others and require longer aging periods. This is an American take on a French cheese that incorporates annatto as well. The cheese is smooth, melts well, and smells sweet and nutty. It’s simple to come by, and if you’re looking to replace American cheese in a cheeseburger or something grilled, this one could be the best option. Because it melts so nicely, it may also be used in mac and cheese.


Similar to Swiss cheese, Havartis is made from sheep’s milk. They are very popular throughout Europe and America. Similar to mozzarella, Havarti is white and firm. Unlike most types of cheese, Havarti does not need to age at all. As long as it’s stored correctly, it’ll keep just fine.

See also  Why put egg in ricotta cheese in lasagna?

If you like your cheese cold, then Havarti might be right up your alley. Although it is a Danish cheese, it might easily pass for an American cheese replacement. Havarti is a mellow, creamy cheese with a number of small holes known as "eyes." It’s more of a Colby cheese in flavor.

Swiss cheese

The original Swiss cheese was created in Switzerland during the Middle Ages. Today, there are many different variations of Swiss cheese available. Some include Gruyere, Emmentaler, Appenzeller, Tilsit, Vacherin Fribourgeois, and Comte.

All these varieties are made using raw milk and are usually quite soft. However, some versions are firmer and drier. Although Swiss cheese isn’t technically American cheese, it’s still worth mentioning here. You’re familiar with this one. The traditional hole-ridden cheese that we all know and love. Swiss cheese does not melt as well as the other cheeses on our list, but in a cheeseburger, it will become quite soft. It also has the benefit of being somewhat aged, which gives it a nuttier, sweeter fragrance that complements any sandwich.


In conclusion, I hope my article helped you find replacements for American cheese. There are plenty of options out there, and each one offers its own benefits. For example, cheddar cheese is great when making sandwiches, while provolone is better suited for pizza toppings.

So, don’t feel limited by what I’ve listed above. Use whatever cheese you want! Just make sure to read labels carefully before purchasing. Also, remember that cheese should never be heated over 140 degrees Fahrenheit. I hope this article helped you with all your food curiosities.

Similar Posts