Boiled Custard VS Eggnog Differences And FAQs

Boiling custard is a traditional method of preparing custard. It is used to make custards such as crème anglaise, crème caramel, and crème brûlée. In order to make a good custard, you need to follow certain steps.

First, you need to separate eggs into two bowls. Then, you need to beat the egg yolks until they become thick and pale become thick and pale yellow. Next, you need to combine the egg yolk and sugar together. After that, you need to add milk slowly while stirring constantly. Finally, you need to mix the egg mixture with the cream.

Eggnog is a traditional holiday drink that is usually served warm. It is made from eggs, milk, sugar, rum, brandy, vanilla extract, nutmeg, cinnamon, and sometimes other spices. The most popular type of eggnog has three ingredients: whole eggs, heavy whipping cream, and bourbon whiskey or dark rum. You can also use light whipped cream instead of heavy whipping cream if you want it lighter in flavor.

Seasonal beverages are already on our minds and hitting the shelves in various places as the weather cools and the holidays approach. Eggnog and boiling custard, two of our favorite holiday beverages, are two of the most popular. Some people may be perplexed as to what boiling custard and eggnog are. Isn’t it the same thing? No, no, and no.

Many major components in boiled custard and eggnog are the same, including milk (milk, half-and-half, cream), sugar, eggs, and vanilla. However, there are a few major distinctions between the two beverages.

Boiled custard VS eggnog

Eggnog is a traditional Christmas drink that has been enjoyed for centuries. It is traditionally served at holiday parties and celebrations. However, there is another type of eggnog that is gaining popularity among health-conscious people.

Boiled Custard is a popular dessert that is often served during the holidays. It is also known as baked custard. The difference between boiled custard and eggnog is that boiled custard contains eggs while eggnog does not.

Both types of eggnog contain milk, sugar, cream, and spices. They both taste delicious and are perfect for holiday parties. However, the boiled custard is healthier because it doesn’t contain raw eggs.

See also  Can you mix ammonia and vinegar?

If you want to enjoy a healthy version of eggnog, boil the custard instead of using raw eggs. Because the yolks have been cooked completely, the boiled custard is thick, whereas eggnog is considerably more liquid and hasn’t been cooked. As a result, eggnog is served chilled, but custard can be served both cold and warm (warm is traditional).

Finally, cooked custard has a more straightforward flavor, resembling a sweetened vanilla milkshake. Spicier eggnog is prepared with cinnamon, nutmeg, and mace. Eggnog can contain alcohol, which people either love or despise. Boiling custard never contains any alcohol. Let’s take a closer look at these discrepancies now, shall we?

The difference in taste

When opposed to eggnog, the boiled custard is a Southern holiday drink and custom that has a milder flavor. It tastes like a thinned-out vanilla milkshake, but with a whipped and thicker texture.

Vanilla is the most common flavor for boiling custard, with a few outliers when a pinch of cinnamon is added. It’s a sweet drink that’s light and gentle. Eggnog has a sweeter flavor than boiling custard, and some people compare it to melted-liquid ice cream. When alcohol is added to eggnog, the flavor of the drink changes, becoming more exotic with a rich and peppery tang.

For taste, cinnamon, mace, nutmeg, and vanilla are commonly added in different amounts to eggnog. The flavor of the alcohol will also vary things significantly, with rum being the most frequent. It’s only a smidgeon.

One of the main differences between boiled custard and regular eggnog is their texture. While boiled custards tend to be thicker than eggnogs, this isn’t always true. There are many different kinds of custards available today, so you should experiment to find one that suits your tastes best.

Another important distinction between boiled custard and normal eggnog is how much fat each beverage contains. Most recipes call for about 1/3 cup of butter per serving.

How they’re prepared

While boiled custard is usually made from scratch, eggnog is typically bought pre-made. This means that the ingredients aren’t mixed together until just before consumption.

This makes sense if you think about it: You wouldn’t mix up all the components of an omelet right after buying them. Instead, you’d wait until you’re ready to eat it.

A double boiler is used to make the boiled custard. Sugar, salt, eggs, heated milk, vanilla, and flour or cornstarch are among the components. The thickness of boiled custard is achieved by adding cold water and more flour (or cornstarch) to the original recipe. It’s almost as thick as pudding and is generally served warm.

See also  Dark VS White Chocolate 4 Key Differences

Raw egg yolks, milk, sugar, heavy cream, and spice are among the components in eggnog (nutmeg, cinnamon, or vanilla). Of course, there are lots of recipes that call for mixing the egg yolks with boiling milk, which also heats them. The raw egg technique is not for everyone.

How to store eggnog and boiled custard

Eggnog tends to keep well in the refrigerator, while boiled custard needs to be kept on the stovetop. If stored properly, both drinks won’t spoil. However, if left out too long, they’ll start losing moisture.

If you want to freeze eggnog, do so within two weeks of making it. Otherwise, don’t bother freezing it because its quality will suffer greatly.

Canned eggnog

Cans of eggnog may be kept in the refrigerator for up to 5 months if they are not opened. Eggnog, on the other hand, maybe kept in the fridge for up to one week once opened. We recommend wrapping it in excellent plastic wrap to keep it sealed.

Store-bought eggnog

Store-bought eggnogs are usually sold in cartons or cans. They are usually made from eggs, sugar, milk, rum, brandy, vanilla extract, and other flavorings. Eggnog is traditionally served hot, but it can also be served cold. It is sometimes called eggnog, nog, or egg-nog.

Store-bought eggnog keeps for 3-4 days in the refrigerator, whether it’s been opened or not. This is primarily due to the fact that it’s raw egg, which means it won’t survive long.

Homemade eggnog

When kept in the refrigerator, homemade eggnog lasts approximately 3 days. Make careful to cover the top with plastic wrap or an airtight container.

Custard that has been boiled

Boiled custard should be stored in a glass jar and kept refrigerated for 2-3 days before releasing moisture.

How to keep eggnog fresh for longer

Eggnog doesn’t have any preservatives; therefore, it spoils quickly when exposed to heat. To prevent this, we suggest keeping your eggnog in the freezer instead of the fridge.

The best way to preserve eggnog is to use powdered gelatin. Powdered gelatin comes in packets and dissolves easily into liquid. Once dissolved, it helps stabilize the mixture and prevents separation. Gelatin powder is available at most grocery stores.

  • Store it at the back of your refrigerator on a bottom shelf to keep it away from light.
  • Eggnog should not be stored on the door storage shelves since it will be exposed to more light and higher temperatures.
  • When not in use, keep eggnog in its original container and make sure the lid is securely fastened.
See also  Ricotta VS Cream Cheese – 3 Differences How To Use Them

Is it possible to freeze eggnog?

Yes! You can freeze eggnog just like ice cubes. Just follow these steps:

1) Pour 1 cup of eggnog into each individual serving bowl.

2) Cover tightly with aluminum foil.

3) Place bowls in the freezer until frozen solid.

4) Remove from the freezer and transfer to a zip lock bag.

5) Store in the freezer for up to 6 months.

6) Thaw overnight in the refrigerator.

7) Serve chilled.

You can freeze eggnog, but the outcome will be disappointing. The texture of the eggnog changes drastically when frozen and then defrosted. It will become clumpy and have a strange texture.

If you don’t mind the texture, eggnog may be stored in the freezer for up to three months over the expiration date and is still safe to eat.

Can you freeze boiled custard?

You may get a really good ice cream texture by freezing cooked custard in small batches. You’ll have to take it out every half hour to stir it, otherwise, you’ll end up with ice crystals. However, if you do it this way, you’ll have a delicious after-dinner dessert! What about canned eggnog?

It’s perfectly fine to store canned eggnog in the pantry as well. Canned eggnog does last much longer than store-bought versions because they’re pasteurized. Pasteurization kills off bacteria so there’s no need to worry about spoilage.

However, canned eggnog tends to separate once thawed. If you want to avoid this problem, add some cornstarch to the mix before pouring it into the containers.


In conclusion, I hope my article helped answer all your questions regarding boiling eggs and making eggnog.

I hope my post helped you with all your food curiosities.

Similar Posts