Sticky Cookie Dough Why It’s Not Good And How To Fix It

Cookie dough is a mixture of flour, sugar, butter, eggs, milk, vanilla extract, salt, baking powder, and sometimes chocolate chips. It’s a simple recipe, but there are so many variations out there.

You might think that cookie dough is only for cookies, but it can also be used as a topping for ice cream, cakes, pies, and even pizza. If you’re looking for an easy dessert recipe that’s healthy and delicious, then cookie dough is perfect for you.

Sticky cookie dough is a nightmare. It’s sticky, it’s hard to spread out, and it’s impossible to roll into balls. If you’ve ever tried making it, you know exactly what I mean.

But there’s a solution. In this article, I’ll tell you how to fix sticky cookie dough and give you some tips on how to make it better.

Why is cookie dough sticky?

The main reason why cookie dough gets stuck together is that the ingredients have not been mixed well enough. The dry ingredients should be combined with the wet ingredients before adding any other ingredients like oil or egg whites. This will help prevent your batter from sticking together when rolling it out.

If you don’t mix them properly, the gluten in the wheat flour won’t develop fully, which means that the dough won’t hold its shape very well. You’ll end up having trouble spreading it around evenly.

If you want to learn more about mixing techniques, check out my video tutorial here!

How do I get rid of the stickiness?

The best way to deal with sticky cookie dough is by using a stand mixer instead of hand-mixing. Stand mixers work much faster than hand mixers because they use powerful motors that turn at high speeds. They beat everything thoroughly without leaving lumps behind.

See also  Can you eat canned corn raw?

Stand mixers come with different attachments depending on their size. For example, if you need to knead bread dough, you’d probably choose one with a large bowl attachment. But if you just need to whip air into whipped cream, you could go with something smaller such as a whisk attachment.

Chill It

You can try chilling the dough by keeping it in the fridge overnight. Chilling helps reduce the amount of moisture in the dough, which makes it easier to handle. However, keep in mind that refrigerating the dough may cause it to lose flavor. So, if possible, let the dough sit at room temperature until ready to bake.

To make the cookies, the butter in the dough was most likely melted, or at least softened, causing the dough to become soft, malleable (maybe even runny), and sticky. You don’t want it to be too sticky, even though it should be soft and malleable. That would result in tough baked goods.

So, while you shouldn’t add extra water to the dough, you should definitely chill it first. Then, once chilled, remove the dough from the refrigerator and allow it to warm back up slightly. Once warmed, gently fold the dough over itself several times. Don’t worry; folding doesn’t change the texture of the dough. Just make sure that all the pieces are folded together nicely.

Add More Flour

Another option is to add extra flour while working with the dough. When you first start mixing the dough, add 1/2 cup of additional flour.

Then continue adding small amounts of flour every time you stir the dough. Eventually, you’ll reach a point where the dough becomes too stiff to work with anymore. At this stage, you’ve added enough flour to stop the dough from becoming overly moist. If necessary, add another tablespoon of flour.

See also  How long does coffee stay good in the fridge? (3 things to know)

Once you’re done making the dough, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap so that no steam escapes. Refrigerate for an hour or two before baking. if you don’t add enough additional flour, the cookies will flatten out excessively. This happens when there’s not enough gluten development during cooking. The excess moisture causes the cookies to spread out too thin.

Cookies Are Ready When…

When your cookies have cooled completely after being removed from the oven, they should look shiny and smooth. If they still seem wet inside, place them under the broiler briefly to dry off any remaining liquid.

What Causes Sticky Cookie Dough?

There are many reasons why cookie dough might stick to the sides of its container. Here are some common culprits:

The Biggest Cookie Baking Mistakes People Make and How to Avoid Them

Too Much Butter

If you used more butter than was called for in the recipe, then the dough won’t hold together properly. In fact, it might actually fall apart. Try reducing the amount of butter next time around.

When you make use of too much butter, the fat molecules get stuck between each other instead of sticking to the surface. As a result, the dough gets very heavy and is difficult to move.

The Eggs Were Too Large

Egg size matters! Egg yolks contain lecithin, which acts as a binder. But egg whites do not. Therefore, using large eggs means that less protein is present in the batter. Fewer protein results in weaker cookies.

Use smaller eggs next time around. They tend to produce lighter-textured cookies because their proteins aren’t as strong. Using the right-sized eggs is important as well. For example, if you were to bake a batch of chocolate chip cookies, you’d need larger eggs than what you’d use for plain vanilla ones.

You Used Volume Measurements

Volume measurements can be tricky. You may think that one teaspoon equals four tablespoons but that isn’t always true. One teaspoon contains about 4 grams whereas four tablespoons hold 16 grams. So, if you measure by volume rather than weight, you could end up with way too much flour or shortening.

See also  Does oyster sauce go bad?

To avoid these problems, weigh ingredients whenever possible. Also, remember that measuring cups come in different sizes. Make sure you know how big yours is before you begin.

Can You Bake Sticky Cookie Dough?

Yes, you absolutely can bake sticky cookie dough. However, you must follow certain guidelines first. First, let the dough cool down completely before attempting to roll it into balls.

Second, try rolling the dough on parchment paper instead of directly onto a pan. Third, keep the rolled dough refrigerated until ready to cook. Fourth, once baked, allow the cookies to sit at room temperature for 10 minutes before serving. Finally, serve immediately while hot. These steps help prevent the cookies from spreading too far.

However, the results won’t be quite as good as those made without this problem. Still, they’ll taste great. Just be careful not to overbake them. Overcooking makes the cookies tough and chewy.


As long as you’re aware of the potential pitfalls when baking sticky cookie dough, there’s no reason why you shouldn’t enjoy delicious treats every now and again. The key is knowing exactly what causes the issue so you don’t repeat mistakes. Hopefully, we’ve helped clear things up here today.

Similar Posts