Why Did My Bread Collapse During Proofing Or Baking

Proofing is a process where you bake a recipe before cooking it. It’s done to ensure that the recipe has been prepared correctly and that there aren’t any errors. The purpose of proofing is to prevent food poisoning.

Baking is a process where you heat ingredients together until they reach a certain temperature. It’s used to cook foods such as bread, cakes, cookies, pies, etc.

Bread is a staple food in almost every household. It is used in sandwiches, toast, pasta dishes, soups, salads, etc. However, bread is also prone to collapse during proofing or baking.

If you are experiencing this problem, then there could be several reasons behind it. Here are some of the possible causes of bread collapse.

Why Did Your Dough Collapse?

I was making bread today and noticed that the dough had collapsed into a ball shape. It looked like it was ready to rise but then it started to collapse. The dough didn’t even stick to the bowl.

My Bread Collapses in the Oven, What am I Doing Wrong?

It’s conceivable that your yeast has gone bad if it’s been sitting in your cupboard for months or wasn’t properly stored, and your dough will remain a solid lump of glutenous dough. Because it is the sole leavener in the dough, yeast is probably the most important component of the pizza. Without it, nothing can happen to the dough. If you have no idea how long your yeast has been around, try using fresh yeast instead. You may need to add more flour when mixing the dough because the amount of water required by the new yeast might not be enough.

Another reason why your dough collapsed is due to too much sugar. Sugar makes the dough sticky so it won’t easily fall out of the container. This means that the dough needs less time to rest after being mixed.

There are several reasons why your bread might collapse. Some of these reasons are obvious while others are less obvious.

Here are some possible causes for your bread to collapse:

A Lack Of Gluten Development

Gluten development occurs naturally over time. When wheat berries are ground up, proteins called gliadin and glutenin form bonds with each other.

See also  Why does my bread smell yeasty?

These bonds create elasticity which allows the dough to expand without breaking apart. As the dough rests, the protein chains bond further and become stronger. Eventually, the dough becomes firm and doesn’t break apart anymore.

However, if you don’t let the dough develop its own gluten, then you’ll end up with a flat loaf. To get rid of this issue, use active dry yeast rather than instant yeast. Active dry yeasts contain enzymes that help activate gluten formation. Instant yeast contains only one enzyme – diastase. Diastase breaks down starch molecules into simple sugars. Since diastase isn’t present in active dry yeasts, they produce better results.

You should always store your yeast in a cool place away from direct sunlight. Yeast tends to grow faster at warmer temperatures. Also, make sure that your yeast hasn’t expired.

Underkneading means kneading the dough just until all ingredients come together. Over-kneaded doughs tend to crack as they bake. Underneath your dough before shaping it.

Overmixing your dough leads to an uneven distribution of air bubbles throughout the dough. These bubbles cause the crust to puff up and give off steam. They also allow moisture to escape through tiny cracks. In addition, undermixed doughs tend to shrink as they cook. Using the wrong flour can lead to poor texture and flavor. For example, adding whole grain flours such as rye flour or oat bran can result in dense loaves. On the contrary, white flour gives off lots of gas during baking.

If you’re unsure about whether your dough is well developed, take a look at the surface of the dough. A smooth surface indicates good gluten development. If you forget the salt , there could be holes on top of the dough. The presence of holes shows that the dough was poorly handled.

If you notice any signs of fermentation, throw out the batch immediately. Fermentation usually happens within 24 hours but sometimes takes longer depending on temperature.

The Poke Test

This test will tell you how long your dough has been sitting around. Take a small amount of dough and poke it with your finger. It’s best to do this when the dough is cold because warm dough may stick to your fingers.

See also  Is It Safe To Use Propane Grill Indoors All You Need To Know!

You want to see little indentations where your finger went in. Ideally, the indentation shouldn’t disappear completely even though the dough feels soft. This tells you that the dough wasn’t allowed enough time for gluten development. You can either add more resting time or increase the hydration level by using less water.

When I first started making bread, my bread would collapse after proofing. After some research, I found that I had used too much yeast. So instead of increasing the amount of yeast, I decreased the amount of water. Now, my bread rises beautifully!

The Windowpane Test

To determine whether your dough is ready to shape, roll it between two sheets of parchment paper. Roll it back and forth so that it stretches like a windowpane.

When rolled thin, the dough should stretch without tearing. If it tears easily, continue rolling it thinner until it becomes pliable again. Once it reaches this stage, remove the parchment papers and cut the dough into pieces.

It Was Overproofed

Bread over-proofed while rising doesn’t have any problems except for one: It won’t rise properly. To fix this problem, simply let the loaf rest for 5 minutes then try again.

Why Did My Bread Fail? Reasons Why Your Bread Failed (& Solutions) –  Bakestarters

I’m not sure what happened here. Maybe I didn’t mix the dough thoroughly enough. But now I know better next time. If your dough over-proof then it’s because you’ve added too many leaveners than are needed. Try reducing the amount of yeast slightly. Also, if you use instant dry yeast, make sure to dissolve it in hot liquid rather than cold.

No matter how much yeast is in the dough or how strong the gluten network is, it can overproof. The dough doesn’t always collapse when it is overproof, so by the time you get around to baking it, you might not even realize it’s over-proofed. That’s why we call them "overbaked" loaves.

A lot of people think that their bread isn’t baked correctly unless it collapses. However, most bread doesn’t need to be fully collapsed before being removed from the oven. Instead, they just need to reach a certain point of brownness. When you bake bread, you’ll find that it gets darker as it bakes. As soon as it starts getting dark, pull it out of the oven.

See also  What to do if there is too much yeast in the bread?

Your Dough Was Too Wet

Doughs made with high amounts of flour tend to become wetter during mixing and shaping. They also take longer to rise. In addition, they’re harder to work with since they don’t hold together well.

In order to prevent these issues, reduce the amount of flour you use. For example, if you normally use 1 cup of all-purpose flour, try using only half that amount. Alternatively, you could substitute whole wheat flour for part of the white flour. If you still experience trouble, consider adding an extra tablespoon of oil at the end of the kneading process. This will help keep the dough moist.

If the dough was too wet, there may be something wrong with your ingredients. Make sure that you measure accurately and that your measuring cups aren’t leaking. Use fresh eggs whenever possible. And remember to grease your bowl very well.

You Damaged The Dough

Sometimes, damage occurs during handling. You might accidentally knock down the sides of the container holding the dough.

Or maybe you dropped the dough on the floor. Whatever caused the damage, once you notice it, stop working immediately. Don’t worry about cleaning up the mess; just put everything away and wait for the dough to recover. Then start over.

This happens more often than you’d expect. People usually assume that damaged dough means bad luck. But really, it’s no different than having a broken piece of glass in your house. Sure, it makes things messy, but it’s nothing serious. Just clean it up and move on.


The best way to avoid these mistakes is to practice. Practice making lots of small batches until you feel comfortable doing it without error. Once you do, you’ll never forget!

Similar Posts